Well, here's how I view it. If you have a warranty you should be covered no matter what you do. The problem is that if you have the warranty you still have to make 100% sure that you perform all the recommended service to the car or you will be held financially responsible for whatever could happen. Not only do you need to be sure to do all the service, which you'll have to pay for on your own, you'll also need to be sure to keep all your records to prove you've done the scheduled work as suggested in the maintenance book. So, if you usually keep very good care of your cars and perform service by the book whether you feel it's needed or not then either transmission should be fine. On the other hand, the CVT is well documented as having more problems so even if you are covered and something happens you'll still have to consider the time of being without a car (about a week in my case) as well as having to incur the cost of a rental during that time. The plus side about the CVT is that it is usually a couple grand cheaper and it's a really smooth ride. I drive about 40 miles to work each day and average usually over 31 mpg when traffic is normal, so I get about 400 or slightly more miles out of each tank of gas. I have heard that the quattro gas mileage is not as good but I can't imagine it's terrible. My wife had an 01 quattro before we got this car and we never had any type of problems with it and honestly, I couldn't say that it shifted any better or worse. So, in the end, it's really all up to what your preferences are. The quattro will obviously have its advantages in poor driving conditions but again I think that either way, if you're covered by a warranty and you make sure to keep your records you should be safe with either choice. The bottom line is no matter what you choose, be sure to get a warranty to guarantee yourself piece of mind which should help you to enjoy whatever car you decide to go with. Just remember, as you should well understand by now... I'll say it again anyway, be sure to get a warranty. One other thing, don't think that you have to pay what the dealer is trying to charge for the warranty. In my case, after my issue, I went back to the dealer and they wanted me to pay a couple thousand more for the same warranty that I got from a 3rd party. If you do choose to go with a 3rd party warranty company just make sure that your warranty is in place BEFORE you drive your car off the lot. I used warrantydirect and the process was very simple. The whole process took about 10 min. and a credit card and the warranty was active before I drove my car out of the mechanic's shop. One last side note, some warranties (depending upon the mileage and year of your car may take 30 days to become active so be sure you get all the details before you make your final decision. Hope that helps,